Announcing a change:
Please enjoy this post, then checkout my new location -YoungonTrials.com Thank you, Steve
You Can’t Get Them Out of the Jury Box With Dynamite.
A potential juror is an animal of strange mien. Upon receiving a jury summons, they may have called friends asking, "How can I get out of jury service?" When they arrive on the fateful day and sit in the jury assembly room, they pray they are not called to the courtroom. When their name is read and they are sent to a courtroom, they calculate the odds of escaping the 12 seats in the box, because the last thing they want is to be put on a jury, until . . . they are put in the box. Then a strange phenomenon occurs. You as an attorney, facing these people who are so resistant to being on a jury, can’t get them out of the jury box with dynamite.
I have seen it over and over again. I finally figured that the reason someone who wanted more than anything to not get on the jury, is suddenly in love with the jury box. No one wants to be rejected. No one wants to hear, "You aren’t good enough for our jury." They rue the walk out of the jury box with all eyes in the courtroom focused on them as they pick up their book, their coat, their bag and are told to return to the assembly room – "We don’t want you on our jury,"
With this dynamic in mind, I had no idea what I was going to do during jury selection on a very big case. Both sides had exercised all their peremptory challenges (because there were horrible people for both sides in that venire panel). The clerk seated four additional prospective jurors. I felt I was in trouble when I arose to ask my questions and prospective juror number 11 crossed his arms and glared at me.
No One Will Admit, "I Am Prejudiced."
Most attorneys I have encountered do not know how to establish the foundation to dismiss a juror for cause. No one will admit, "I am prejudiced." A few will say, "I can’t be fair," but don’t stake your case on that happening.
I posed opening questions to Juror number 11. His answers scared the hell out of me. I had to stand there like the bull fighter who stares into the charging bull’s eyes no matter the fear in his heart. I had to absorb his abuse knowing I had no peremptory challenges left.
It’s not easy having your client attacked in front of the other jurors. It’s not easy remaining calm when you’re attacked. I worried, would this affect the other jurors? Were his answers ruining any chance at a fair trial?
My matador’s cape suddenly seemed very small as the beast charged my case.
I don’t know where it came from, but I responded with an observation, "Sir, you seem to me to be a person who is highly principled."
He acted like he did not know how to respond to this after his attacks. "Well, I yes I think I am."
"Your principles are very important to you aren't they?"
"Yes."
"Are you concerned that if you sit on this jury that you will be asked to set aside your principles by the attorneys or the judge or the law?"
"Now that you mention it, I guess that you’re right."
"And you don’t like that do you?"
'No."
"That really bothers you doesn’t it? Because your principles are really important to you aren’t they?"
"Yes they are."
"They are important to you because they make you who you are don’t they?"
"Yes they do."
"You wouldn’t give them up would you, not for anyone?"
"I hope I wouldn’t have to make that choice."
"No one should have to. Let me ask you this. What if during this trial someone tells you that you must do something that you think is contrary to your principles?"
"Like what?"
"What if the judge instructs you and the other jurors that if you find certain things, you have to give an award that is against what you think is right? That would be asking you to give up your principles wouldn’t it?"
"Yes, I guess."
"Would you do it?"
"Do what?"
"Give up your principles that you hold dear, would you give them up?"
"I don’t think I would like that."
"None of us would like that, but what I am asking is: would you set aside your principles to rule in this case?"
"I don’t think I would."
"Why not?"
"I think principles are what make us who we are. A man without principles is not much of a man in my view."
"Exactly. You have summarized what you feel in that one sentence haven’t you? If you relinquish your principles, you relinquish yourself."
"Yes that’s right."
"And that’s true whether it is me asking you to do it, or the defense attorney, right."
"That’s right."
"What if it’s the judge asking you to put your principles aside? What if he instructs you that are to do something and you don’t agree with it?"
"I wouldn’t do that."
"It doesn’t matter what it is he’s telling you, if you feel it’s against your principles, you’re not going to do it are you."
"No."
"What if the judge is instructing you on the law and you think the law is contrary to your principles. You wouldn’t follow the instruction would you?"
"No."
"Because you won’t do something that is against your principles, even if it’s the judge telling you to do it, right?"
"That’s right."
"Thank you for your honesty, sir. It takes a brave man to tell a judge that your principles are more important to you than what the judge might instruct you to do."
When time came to challenge the potential jurors for cause, I succeeded over my adversaries arguments to get the principled man excused because he told the judge that he would not follow the instructions if they conflicted with his principles. Less than this and the court will probably not strike for cause and you better have a peremptory in your bag.
Announcing a change:
Please enjoy this post, then checkout my new location -YoungonTrials.com Thank you, Steve
Would You Please Help Me?
I am in the process of developing a free webinar series on a unique method I have developed for conducting jury selection. This method facilitates juror interaction and the development of relationships in the jury. I intend to make this a 6-session webinar and go in depth on how to become powerful at voir dire. You can help me develop these programs and assure that I cover every important issue. Please send an email to Bestlawyer@aol.com with your questions about jury selection. If you are interested in getting a notice when I'm ready to launch the webinars, send me an email with your name and request a notice.
Showing posts with label examination. Show all posts
Showing posts with label examination. Show all posts
Friday, July 11, 2014
Jury Selection: Can You Be the Matador Facing the Charging Bull?
Labels:
attorneys,
challenge for cause,
examination,
juror,
juror strikes,
jury questioning,
jury questions,
jury selection,
jury trial,
lawyers,
peremptory challenge,
preemptory challenge,
venire,
voir dire
Friday, June 27, 2014
Qualify Your Expert Without Putting the Jury to Sleep.
What is the most boring portion of any trial? I’ll give a hint:
Imagine You are a Juror . . .
A juror summons holds you prisoner for a civil trial. The witnesses have ranged from personable to downright boring. The plaintiff now calls a witness whose suit has a silk sheen showing it is more expensive than even the defense attorney's suit. His hair is immaculately styled. Unlike the other witnesses who were nervous when called, he exudes an air of confidence when he enters the courtroom. Unlike the other witnesses who seemed lost in the unfamiliar courtroom, he knows where to go to be sworn in, who to face, how to act. He carries a box full of paper to the witness stand. You think, how long will it take to work through all that paper?
The plaintiff’s attorney first question to this witness seeks strange to you, "Please describe your educational background." The witness turns to the jury and smiles showing perfect teeth. He recites a list of prep schools, colleges and graduate schools. He talks about his degrees and expounds on his impeccable pedigree – none of which you have. This witness really enjoys telling you that he’s smart.
The plaintiff’s attorney asks another question. "Have you published any books or papers?" Again the witness pivots to face you and smiles before beginning his answer. You pretty quickly understand, "This guy would never talk to me at a party." The longer he talks about himself, the more you dread having to listen to him. Forty-five minutes pass and finally the attorney asks, "Sir can you tell us how the accident happened?"
What is the Most Boring Part of Any Trial?
I pose my question again: What is the most boring portion of every trial? What is the phase of trial that most separates the jury from your case? During what part of trial does the jury least understand what the trial attorney is doing? It is the snore-fest called, "Qualifying an Expert."
I was subjected to this torture so many times that I adopted a different approach. I noticed jurors were just as bored as I was while my opponent qualified his expert. Unfortunately, I had already presented several expert witnesses during that trial and was oblivious to the effect it was having on the jury. I set about looking for a different way to present experts. Fortunately, television presented an answer. It wasn’t a method embedded in the plot, instead it was a marketing tool.
The Hook – How Television Keeps You From Touching That Dial
I noticed that at the end of a television program, the station did not play commercials. Instead, they played a short segment of the upcoming program that "hooked" the audience. The reason the programs are set up this way is to create interest so you remain with the program during the standard opening for the program, and the first round of commercials. A dead body, or a personal conflict, or a problem is thrown at you to get you thinking, "I need to know how she’s going to get out of this." It’s marketing. It works. If the hook is good enough, you will not change the channel even if it means missing your favorite program.
The regular presentation at trial does not use the hook. Instead of presenting something in which the jury may be interested at the beginning, the ordinary trial lawyer starts running the "credits" at the beginning of the show. Not a very deep hook. Do you think the jury would change the station if they could?
How Can We Use the Hook at Trial?
I developed a way of presenting experts that is loosely based on the "Hook." There may be a better way to do it, but this is what I am doing now.
I try to teach the jury as much as I can because most people have a natural curiosity and find learning interesting. When I first call an expert to the stand, I want to teach them what an expert is and why this witness is on the stand. I do this by asking:
"What is your occupation or vocation?"
"Can you describe what that is?"
Now comes the hook:
"Have I hired you to analyze aspects of this case and share opinions with the jury based on your expertise to assist the jury in ruling in this case?"
I’m introducing why the witness is at trial, and that the witness can actually help the jury with their task, thus creating a willingness to pay attention to someone who is there to make things easier for the jurors.
"Have you preformed your analysis?"
"Are you prepared to share your opinions with this jury?"
Here comes the critical component of my presentation: I want the jury to understand why I must walk the expert through their qualifications and the work performed to reach the conclusions. The jury, understanding this, knows it is important.
"Before I have you share your opinions with this jury, I need to walk you through what qualifies you to come into this trial to share your expertise with the jury. May I do that?"
After completing the discussion of the expert’s qualifications, I shift to the work to collect all the information and documents, and the steps taken to perform the analysis. It is only after I have done that, and the jury understands the work the expert performed, that I ask the opinions.
I feel the Hook method of presenting experts makes the use of experts more understandable to the jurors and helps them understand that the expert is there to make their task easier.
Check back each Friday for my posting of new installments of Young on Trial.
I have published two small books to help the ordinary person with employment issues. They are for sale at Amazon.com for only 99 cents each. One is called "You’re Fired!" and the other is called "I Quit My Job!" Please refer anyone who could benefit from direct answers to employees’ questions during difficult times.
Until next Friday, thank you for reading.
Imagine You are a Juror . . .
A juror summons holds you prisoner for a civil trial. The witnesses have ranged from personable to downright boring. The plaintiff now calls a witness whose suit has a silk sheen showing it is more expensive than even the defense attorney's suit. His hair is immaculately styled. Unlike the other witnesses who were nervous when called, he exudes an air of confidence when he enters the courtroom. Unlike the other witnesses who seemed lost in the unfamiliar courtroom, he knows where to go to be sworn in, who to face, how to act. He carries a box full of paper to the witness stand. You think, how long will it take to work through all that paper?
The plaintiff’s attorney first question to this witness seeks strange to you, "Please describe your educational background." The witness turns to the jury and smiles showing perfect teeth. He recites a list of prep schools, colleges and graduate schools. He talks about his degrees and expounds on his impeccable pedigree – none of which you have. This witness really enjoys telling you that he’s smart.
The plaintiff’s attorney asks another question. "Have you published any books or papers?" Again the witness pivots to face you and smiles before beginning his answer. You pretty quickly understand, "This guy would never talk to me at a party." The longer he talks about himself, the more you dread having to listen to him. Forty-five minutes pass and finally the attorney asks, "Sir can you tell us how the accident happened?"
What is the Most Boring Part of Any Trial?
I pose my question again: What is the most boring portion of every trial? What is the phase of trial that most separates the jury from your case? During what part of trial does the jury least understand what the trial attorney is doing? It is the snore-fest called, "Qualifying an Expert."
I was subjected to this torture so many times that I adopted a different approach. I noticed jurors were just as bored as I was while my opponent qualified his expert. Unfortunately, I had already presented several expert witnesses during that trial and was oblivious to the effect it was having on the jury. I set about looking for a different way to present experts. Fortunately, television presented an answer. It wasn’t a method embedded in the plot, instead it was a marketing tool.
The Hook – How Television Keeps You From Touching That Dial
I noticed that at the end of a television program, the station did not play commercials. Instead, they played a short segment of the upcoming program that "hooked" the audience. The reason the programs are set up this way is to create interest so you remain with the program during the standard opening for the program, and the first round of commercials. A dead body, or a personal conflict, or a problem is thrown at you to get you thinking, "I need to know how she’s going to get out of this." It’s marketing. It works. If the hook is good enough, you will not change the channel even if it means missing your favorite program.
The regular presentation at trial does not use the hook. Instead of presenting something in which the jury may be interested at the beginning, the ordinary trial lawyer starts running the "credits" at the beginning of the show. Not a very deep hook. Do you think the jury would change the station if they could?
How Can We Use the Hook at Trial?
I developed a way of presenting experts that is loosely based on the "Hook." There may be a better way to do it, but this is what I am doing now.
I try to teach the jury as much as I can because most people have a natural curiosity and find learning interesting. When I first call an expert to the stand, I want to teach them what an expert is and why this witness is on the stand. I do this by asking:
"What is your occupation or vocation?"
"Can you describe what that is?"
Now comes the hook:
"Have I hired you to analyze aspects of this case and share opinions with the jury based on your expertise to assist the jury in ruling in this case?"
"Have you preformed your analysis?"
"Are you prepared to share your opinions with this jury?"
"Before I have you share your opinions with this jury, I need to walk you through what qualifies you to come into this trial to share your expertise with the jury. May I do that?"
After completing the discussion of the expert’s qualifications, I shift to the work to collect all the information and documents, and the steps taken to perform the analysis. It is only after I have done that, and the jury understands the work the expert performed, that I ask the opinions.
I feel the Hook method of presenting experts makes the use of experts more understandable to the jurors and helps them understand that the expert is there to make their task easier.
Check back each Friday for my posting of new installments of Young on Trial.
I have published two small books to help the ordinary person with employment issues. They are for sale at Amazon.com for only 99 cents each. One is called "You’re Fired!" and the other is called "I Quit My Job!" Please refer anyone who could benefit from direct answers to employees’ questions during difficult times.
Until next Friday, thank you for reading.
Friday, June 13, 2014
An Out-of-the-Box Approach to Controlling the Argumentative Witness
Imagine you are finally in trial after a hard-fought discovery and pretrial process. Your opponent has battled on every point, many times simply to oppose what you want. Your frustration grows as the court rules in your opponent’s favor on motions in limine (pretrial evidence exclusion motions) thus removing from your arsenal some of your best evidence. At each phase of the trial your opponent objects to everything. His strategy continues into your witness examination.
The judge says, "You may call your next witness."
You rise looking at the jury to gage their reaction and announce, "Plaintiff’s next witness is the Defendant, Josiah Wrongful."
Wrongful’s attorney rises, "Your honor we object to Plaintiff calling Mr. Wrongful in their case in chief."
The judge overrules the objection, "Counsel, Plaintiff can call and cross examine the Defendant during their case. Let’s get going."
It is now payback time for all the frustration you have felt throughout the case. You are prepared. Your deposition summaries are at hand and indexed. Each discovery response is marked and you have lodged the original request and response with the judge. Each exhibit you intend to use is arrayed, marked, and cross referenced to other relevant exhibits. You feel power and control racing through you veins as you rise to examine.
But the witness does not play straight. You ask limited questions, leading on cross. But the defendant does not answer either "yes" or "no." He pontificates. You try to cut him off before he can run away with another answer, but your opponent successfully urges the judge to allow the witness to answer the question. You start moving to strike the non-responsive portions of each answer, but watching the jury, you sense they do not understand why you are playing "attorney games" and trying to hide the truth from them.
You fall back to law school. You remember your professor taught, "Ask the judge to instruct the witness to answer the question." Unfortunately, the judge is not willing to do that and responds, "I think the answer is responsive."
What can you do? If the Defendant won’t answer your question straight, most of your prepared cross will not make sense, much less help you.
AN OUT-OF-THE-BOX APPROACH
This suggestion is not for everyone, and definitely not for you if you are facing your first jury trial. It is something that I hit on one day when I was so in the moment at trial that it just came out and worked perfectly.
Assume the same scenario as I described above, but rather than struggling with the witness, simply recognize that the witness has a story he wants to tell and your questions are not going to get in the way, unless you use jiu jitsu and bring him under control.
I was in a trial, with a defendant on the stand, who wanted to argue every question with a narrative answer. I said, "Mr. Wrongful, there is obviously something you feel like I am not letting you say that you feel is important because you are not answering my questions. I am going to allow you to say whatever you feel you need to say to the jury. I am going to sit here, just let me know when you are finished so I can resume my examination."
I then sat down. Opposing counsel did not object, because I have just given the defendant free reign to speak. The judge perked up, looked over his reading glasses at the witness, not knowing what was going to happen, never having seen anything like this. A hush fell on the whole courtroom.
The defendant turned uncomfortably toward the jury and began to speak. You could hear a pin drop. Everyone wanted to hear how this would go. The Defendant spoke for a minute of two, said really nothing, and finally, almost apologetically said, "Mr. Young, please ask me your next question."
I wasn’t willing to let him off quite so easily yet. I asked, "Are you sure you don’t have anything else you need to say to the jury?" He assured me there was not.
I stood up and resumed my examination. If the witness wandered at all in his answer, I asked, "I’m feeling a little tension again between us, is there something else I need to let you tell the jury?"
Each time the Defendant responded, "No, no, ask me the question again." To which he provided a direct answer.
WHY DID THIS WORK?
I was being fair to my opponent. The jury recognized that. When I stated what I believed the jurors were feeling, that the Defendant was being evasive and offered to allow him to talk directly to the jury without me asking questions, he turned to face a jury that was then really irritated with him. I watched the jurors’ faces. They were not friendly and open to the Defendant. Have you ever tried to talk to a group of people who feel hostile to you? That is what the Defendant was doing. The reason he didn’t speak very long is because the jury imposed their own control on him. He knew they did like that he was not playing by the rules. They did not like that he was not answering my questions.
The jury felt like he was wasting their time.
I have had people ask me, "Aren’t you worried about what the Defendant will say? Won’t the Defendant’s uncontrolled speech kill your case?"
My answer is "No." I don’t care what he says in that situation, because the jury is not going to listen to him anyway. Everything he will say, even if Defense counsel reads this at some later time and prepares a speech for their client, it won’t matter to me. The jury will not listen to the speech, and if it is a good speech, they will know the defense attorney prepared it, and really punish the Defendant. That’s because the Defendant is not following the rules, and all I have done is highlight that for the jury.
The proof of that is what happened each time the Defendant started to relapse, and I offered another "free go" at the jury, the witness said "No." That was because he did not want to face the punishing jury again. Once was enough, he did not want to go there a second time. Instead the response to my offer became, "No, just ask your question again.
I’ll answer it."
I don’t use this tactic often, maybe less than once every 10 trials. Opposing counsel who have heard of this tactic have tried to prepare their client with an organized speech. It hasn’t worked. That’s because it is not about the speech, it’s about how the jury reacts.
A FURTHER NOTE:
On occasions where I have used this tactic in trial, I don’t leave it at witness control. In closing argument, I always comment on what happened during that cross examination. It will sound something like, "Who is it that is unafraid of the truth in this case? The Defense insisted that every witness answer their questions with only a ‘yes’ or ‘no’. When I was examining, I gave everyone the chance to explain anything they wanted. I was not afraid of any answer because the truth makes you free. In fact, remember when I was cross examining the Defendant, and he wanted to give speeches rather than answer my questions? I didn’t fight him and insist, ‘just answer yes or no.’ Instead, I sat down and said, ‘tell the jury whatever you want.’ What does that tell you about truth in this case? I didn’t care what he said. All I cared about was you getting to see him and how he acted, even when he was given free reign to say whatever he wanted. That’s because we know that you know what the truth is and who is unafraid here."
When you feel comfortable in trial, try this sometime. It will take great courage, but that is what trial is about: doing the right thing, at the right time, for the right reason.
Check back each Friday for my posting of new installments of Young On Trial.
I have published two small books to help the ordinary person with employment issues. They are for sale at Amazon.com for only 99 cents each. One is called “You’re Fired!” and the other is called “I Quit My Job!” Please refer anyone who could benefit from direct answers to employees’ questions during difficult times.
Until next Friday, thank you for reading.
The judge says, "You may call your next witness."
You rise looking at the jury to gage their reaction and announce, "Plaintiff’s next witness is the Defendant, Josiah Wrongful."
Wrongful’s attorney rises, "Your honor we object to Plaintiff calling Mr. Wrongful in their case in chief."
The judge overrules the objection, "Counsel, Plaintiff can call and cross examine the Defendant during their case. Let’s get going."
It is now payback time for all the frustration you have felt throughout the case. You are prepared. Your deposition summaries are at hand and indexed. Each discovery response is marked and you have lodged the original request and response with the judge. Each exhibit you intend to use is arrayed, marked, and cross referenced to other relevant exhibits. You feel power and control racing through you veins as you rise to examine.
But the witness does not play straight. You ask limited questions, leading on cross. But the defendant does not answer either "yes" or "no." He pontificates. You try to cut him off before he can run away with another answer, but your opponent successfully urges the judge to allow the witness to answer the question. You start moving to strike the non-responsive portions of each answer, but watching the jury, you sense they do not understand why you are playing "attorney games" and trying to hide the truth from them.
You fall back to law school. You remember your professor taught, "Ask the judge to instruct the witness to answer the question." Unfortunately, the judge is not willing to do that and responds, "I think the answer is responsive."
What can you do? If the Defendant won’t answer your question straight, most of your prepared cross will not make sense, much less help you.
AN OUT-OF-THE-BOX APPROACH
This suggestion is not for everyone, and definitely not for you if you are facing your first jury trial. It is something that I hit on one day when I was so in the moment at trial that it just came out and worked perfectly.
Assume the same scenario as I described above, but rather than struggling with the witness, simply recognize that the witness has a story he wants to tell and your questions are not going to get in the way, unless you use jiu jitsu and bring him under control.
I was in a trial, with a defendant on the stand, who wanted to argue every question with a narrative answer. I said, "Mr. Wrongful, there is obviously something you feel like I am not letting you say that you feel is important because you are not answering my questions. I am going to allow you to say whatever you feel you need to say to the jury. I am going to sit here, just let me know when you are finished so I can resume my examination."
I then sat down. Opposing counsel did not object, because I have just given the defendant free reign to speak. The judge perked up, looked over his reading glasses at the witness, not knowing what was going to happen, never having seen anything like this. A hush fell on the whole courtroom.
The defendant turned uncomfortably toward the jury and began to speak. You could hear a pin drop. Everyone wanted to hear how this would go. The Defendant spoke for a minute of two, said really nothing, and finally, almost apologetically said, "Mr. Young, please ask me your next question."
I wasn’t willing to let him off quite so easily yet. I asked, "Are you sure you don’t have anything else you need to say to the jury?" He assured me there was not.
I stood up and resumed my examination. If the witness wandered at all in his answer, I asked, "I’m feeling a little tension again between us, is there something else I need to let you tell the jury?"
Each time the Defendant responded, "No, no, ask me the question again." To which he provided a direct answer.
WHY DID THIS WORK?
I was being fair to my opponent. The jury recognized that. When I stated what I believed the jurors were feeling, that the Defendant was being evasive and offered to allow him to talk directly to the jury without me asking questions, he turned to face a jury that was then really irritated with him. I watched the jurors’ faces. They were not friendly and open to the Defendant. Have you ever tried to talk to a group of people who feel hostile to you? That is what the Defendant was doing. The reason he didn’t speak very long is because the jury imposed their own control on him. He knew they did like that he was not playing by the rules. They did not like that he was not answering my questions.
The jury felt like he was wasting their time.
I have had people ask me, "Aren’t you worried about what the Defendant will say? Won’t the Defendant’s uncontrolled speech kill your case?"
My answer is "No." I don’t care what he says in that situation, because the jury is not going to listen to him anyway. Everything he will say, even if Defense counsel reads this at some later time and prepares a speech for their client, it won’t matter to me. The jury will not listen to the speech, and if it is a good speech, they will know the defense attorney prepared it, and really punish the Defendant. That’s because the Defendant is not following the rules, and all I have done is highlight that for the jury.
The proof of that is what happened each time the Defendant started to relapse, and I offered another "free go" at the jury, the witness said "No." That was because he did not want to face the punishing jury again. Once was enough, he did not want to go there a second time. Instead the response to my offer became, "No, just ask your question again.
I’ll answer it."
I don’t use this tactic often, maybe less than once every 10 trials. Opposing counsel who have heard of this tactic have tried to prepare their client with an organized speech. It hasn’t worked. That’s because it is not about the speech, it’s about how the jury reacts.
A FURTHER NOTE:
On occasions where I have used this tactic in trial, I don’t leave it at witness control. In closing argument, I always comment on what happened during that cross examination. It will sound something like, "Who is it that is unafraid of the truth in this case? The Defense insisted that every witness answer their questions with only a ‘yes’ or ‘no’. When I was examining, I gave everyone the chance to explain anything they wanted. I was not afraid of any answer because the truth makes you free. In fact, remember when I was cross examining the Defendant, and he wanted to give speeches rather than answer my questions? I didn’t fight him and insist, ‘just answer yes or no.’ Instead, I sat down and said, ‘tell the jury whatever you want.’ What does that tell you about truth in this case? I didn’t care what he said. All I cared about was you getting to see him and how he acted, even when he was given free reign to say whatever he wanted. That’s because we know that you know what the truth is and who is unafraid here."
When you feel comfortable in trial, try this sometime. It will take great courage, but that is what trial is about: doing the right thing, at the right time, for the right reason.
Check back each Friday for my posting of new installments of Young On Trial.
I have published two small books to help the ordinary person with employment issues. They are for sale at Amazon.com for only 99 cents each. One is called “You’re Fired!” and the other is called “I Quit My Job!” Please refer anyone who could benefit from direct answers to employees’ questions during difficult times.
Until next Friday, thank you for reading.
Friday, June 6, 2014
3 Problems with Opposing Medical Experts you can Solve with the AMA's Ethical Rules.
The Code of Medical Ethics of the American Medical Association presents fertile ground for counsel to cross examine opposing medical experts. In my experience, most doctors are unaware of these rules and in all cases violate the proscription against disclosing without permission, the plaintiff’s medical information derived from a medical / legal examination.
Problem 1: The Physician Who Demands Payment to Testify.
Invariably when I serve a trial subpoena on a treating physician concerning a client, the doctor immediately demands that I pay an exorbitant fee and threatens to either ignore the subpoena if I don’t pay, or worse threatens to scuttle my case if the judge compels him to testify. Somehow doctors have elevated themselves to paid witnesses no matter their role at trial.
I respond, citing Rule 9.07 "Medical Testimony" of the AMA Ethics Rules, which provides:
"As a citizen and as a professional with special training and experience, the physician has an ethical obligation to assist in the administration of justice. If a patient who has a legal claim requests a physician's assistance, the physician should furnish medical evidence, with the patient's consent, in order to secure the patient's legal rights."
The ethical rules are silent as to any compensation to the doctor, and instead impose an affirmative duty on the doctor to appear and testify.
Problem 2: The Other Side’s Expert Hasn’t Treated a Patient in Years.
What do you do when you encounter the professional witness physician? You know the type; he does not treat patients but makes his living selling insurance medical examinations (IMEs) and delivering damning medical testimony. Rule 9.07 "Medical Testimony" addresses this and gives a rich source for cross examination.
"Medical experts should have recent and substantive experience in the area in which they testify and should limit testimony to their sphere of medical expertise."
A cross examination of a professional medical witness might sound like:
"Please tell the jury how long it has been since you treated a patient."
"Five years ago when you lasted treated a patient, what area of medicine was it in which you were treating that patient?"
"How long ago was it that you last practiced medicine in the area in which you are offering your opinion today?"
"Have you retired from the practice of medicine?"
"I mean, are you still using your medical school training and the experience you obtained caring for the sick and injured to generate income for yourself at the present time?"
"Is that income only from examinations related to court cases, like this one?"
"When you come to court to testify, you are paid as an expert witness , correct?"
"During the past five years, you sole source of income from your medical training has come from serving as a testifying expert for attorneys at trial, correct?"
"Are you a member of the AMA?"
"Please tell the jury what that is."
"Please look at Exhibit 47. For the record your honor, 47 is the American Medical Association’s Code of Ethics. Do you recognize that Doctor?"
"Tell the jury why you haven’t seen this in 30 years."
"Regardless of that, please look at Rule 9.07 "Medical Testimony" of the American Medical Association. It says, ‘Medical experts should have recent and substantive experience in the area in which they testify and should limit testimony to their sphere of medical expertise.’ Please tell the jury what ‘substantive experience’ means."
"Please tell the jury what ‘recent’ means in that rule."
"Please tell the jury why whether you have resigned your membership in the AMA."
"Did you resign your membership in the AMA because you did not want to be a member of an association that says that if you have not treated patients for five years that it is unethical for you to testify in that field?"
"No further questions."
Problem 3: The Opposing Medical Expert Assumes the Role of Advocate.
Who hasn’t confronted the physician at trial who assumes the role of advocate and argues not only the opponent’s case, but sets out to destroy your case, even if the testimony is not medically sound?
Rule 9.07 of the AMA Rules of Ethics tells doctors that they cannot be advocates:
"The medical witness must not become an advocate or a partisan in the legal proceeding. The medical witness should be adequately prepared and should testify honestly and truthfully. The attorney for the party who calls the physician as a witness should be informed of all favorable and unfavorable information developed by the physician's evaluation of the case."
"Doctor, are you here as an advocate for the defense?"
"What does it mean for a doctor to be an advocate in a case?"
"You know you cannot be an advocate, or else you violate the ethical rules of the AMA, correct?"
"You know that part of your obligation to remain neutral and not be an advocate requires you to tell my opponent not only the medical information favorable to his defense, but also the unfavorable information developed during your examination, correct?"
"Please list all the information unfavorable to the defense that you developed during your evaluation of the Plaintiff."
"Why didn’t you note that information?"
"Is safe to assume you did not share that with my opponent?"
"Is it also safe to assume that you did not intend to share that with the jury, unless perchance on cross examination, I asked you specifically about it?"
Note: After getting the doctor to state for the jury that he is not an advocate, if the medical expert begins to slip back into the argumentative role, I bring them back by asking: "Doctor, are you advocating again?" When I do this, the doctor embarrassedly apologizes and affirms, "No, no please ask your question again, I try to answer it."
Check back each Friday for my posting of new installments of Young On Trial.
I have published two small books to help the ordinary person with employment issues. They are for sale at Amazon.com for only 99 cents each. One is called "You’re Fired! " and the other is called "I Quit!" Please refer anyone who could benefit from direct answers to employees’ questions during difficult times. If you have any questions, you can email me, I'll answer.
Until next Friday, thank you for reading.
Problem 1: The Physician Who Demands Payment to Testify.
Invariably when I serve a trial subpoena on a treating physician concerning a client, the doctor immediately demands that I pay an exorbitant fee and threatens to either ignore the subpoena if I don’t pay, or worse threatens to scuttle my case if the judge compels him to testify. Somehow doctors have elevated themselves to paid witnesses no matter their role at trial.
I respond, citing Rule 9.07 "Medical Testimony" of the AMA Ethics Rules, which provides:
"As a citizen and as a professional with special training and experience, the physician has an ethical obligation to assist in the administration of justice. If a patient who has a legal claim requests a physician's assistance, the physician should furnish medical evidence, with the patient's consent, in order to secure the patient's legal rights."
The ethical rules are silent as to any compensation to the doctor, and instead impose an affirmative duty on the doctor to appear and testify.
Problem 2: The Other Side’s Expert Hasn’t Treated a Patient in Years.
What do you do when you encounter the professional witness physician? You know the type; he does not treat patients but makes his living selling insurance medical examinations (IMEs) and delivering damning medical testimony. Rule 9.07 "Medical Testimony" addresses this and gives a rich source for cross examination.
"Medical experts should have recent and substantive experience in the area in which they testify and should limit testimony to their sphere of medical expertise."
A cross examination of a professional medical witness might sound like:
"Please tell the jury how long it has been since you treated a patient."
"Five years ago when you lasted treated a patient, what area of medicine was it in which you were treating that patient?"
"How long ago was it that you last practiced medicine in the area in which you are offering your opinion today?"
"Have you retired from the practice of medicine?"
"I mean, are you still using your medical school training and the experience you obtained caring for the sick and injured to generate income for yourself at the present time?"
"Is that income only from examinations related to court cases, like this one?"
"When you come to court to testify, you are paid as an expert witness , correct?"
"During the past five years, you sole source of income from your medical training has come from serving as a testifying expert for attorneys at trial, correct?"
"Are you a member of the AMA?"
"Please tell the jury what that is."
"Please look at Exhibit 47. For the record your honor, 47 is the American Medical Association’s Code of Ethics. Do you recognize that Doctor?"
"Tell the jury why you haven’t seen this in 30 years."
"Regardless of that, please look at Rule 9.07 "Medical Testimony" of the American Medical Association. It says, ‘Medical experts should have recent and substantive experience in the area in which they testify and should limit testimony to their sphere of medical expertise.’ Please tell the jury what ‘substantive experience’ means."
"Please tell the jury what ‘recent’ means in that rule."
"Please tell the jury why whether you have resigned your membership in the AMA."
"Did you resign your membership in the AMA because you did not want to be a member of an association that says that if you have not treated patients for five years that it is unethical for you to testify in that field?"
"No further questions."
Problem 3: The Opposing Medical Expert Assumes the Role of Advocate.
Who hasn’t confronted the physician at trial who assumes the role of advocate and argues not only the opponent’s case, but sets out to destroy your case, even if the testimony is not medically sound?
Rule 9.07 of the AMA Rules of Ethics tells doctors that they cannot be advocates:
"The medical witness must not become an advocate or a partisan in the legal proceeding. The medical witness should be adequately prepared and should testify honestly and truthfully. The attorney for the party who calls the physician as a witness should be informed of all favorable and unfavorable information developed by the physician's evaluation of the case."
"Doctor, are you here as an advocate for the defense?"
"What does it mean for a doctor to be an advocate in a case?"
"You know you cannot be an advocate, or else you violate the ethical rules of the AMA, correct?"
"You know that part of your obligation to remain neutral and not be an advocate requires you to tell my opponent not only the medical information favorable to his defense, but also the unfavorable information developed during your examination, correct?"
"Please list all the information unfavorable to the defense that you developed during your evaluation of the Plaintiff."
"Why didn’t you note that information?"
"Is safe to assume you did not share that with my opponent?"
"Is it also safe to assume that you did not intend to share that with the jury, unless perchance on cross examination, I asked you specifically about it?"
Note: After getting the doctor to state for the jury that he is not an advocate, if the medical expert begins to slip back into the argumentative role, I bring them back by asking: "Doctor, are you advocating again?" When I do this, the doctor embarrassedly apologizes and affirms, "No, no please ask your question again, I try to answer it."
Check back each Friday for my posting of new installments of Young On Trial.
I have published two small books to help the ordinary person with employment issues. They are for sale at Amazon.com for only 99 cents each. One is called "You’re Fired! " and the other is called "I Quit!" Please refer anyone who could benefit from direct answers to employees’ questions during difficult times. If you have any questions, you can email me, I'll answer.
Until next Friday, thank you for reading.
Labels:
bench trial,
case in chief,
closing argument,
cross,
defendant,
direct evidence,
examination,
expert,
in limine,
judge,
judgment,
jury,
jury selection,
opening,
plaintiff,
pretrial,
verdict,
voir dire
Friday, May 30, 2014
Expert Depositions: The Key Questions
As trial approaches, you have received your opponent's expert disclosure. You've scheduled depositions for your opponent's experts. You have taken several regular depositions in this case, but you have never conducted an expert’s deposition. Your wonder, "What do I do?"
The first key to a successful expert deposition to understand what the deposition of an expert is and what it is not.
What the expert’s deposition is not:
A, An expert deposition is not the time to pull out the great impeachment evidence and examine the expert about it. It does you no good. The jury is not there. By the time you get to trial, you will have given the expert a heads up on what you have, and you will have given the expert time to prepare an answer and act as if it is no big deal despite freaking out in the deposition when first confronted with the impeachment.
B. An expert deposition is not the time to cross examine the expert about matters in his or her opinion that contradict generally accepted science or procedure in the area of the opinion. Again, this is a matter for trial while the trier of fact is looking on.
What the Expert’s deposition is:
The expert’s deposition consists of several things:
A. You want to learn what the expert’s opinion is.
B. You want to learn on what evidence the expert relies for the opinion.
C. You want to learn what the attorney told the expert.
D. You want to learn how long the expert spent formulating the opinion
E. You want to learn whether the expert actually is the one who derived the opinion or if the expert is relying on someone else.
F. You want to learn if there are grounds to exclude the opinion in whole or in part.
G. You want to learn how the expert presents as a witness and if he is persuasive.
What questions should you ask to learn what it is you seek?
1. Please tell your formal background, including resume, books, articles and
lectures. Tell me what projects you are presently working on within your area of expertise.
2. When were you first hired as an expert in this matter? What are the details of your hiring?
3. Please give me your entire file for this matter including notes and memoranda, and calculations. (When you get the documents, go through them and identify each document. Some attorneys attach all of the expert’s file to the deposition as an exhibit.) Have you discarded anything concerning this case since you were hired? What was that? Why?
4. How many hours have you spent working on this matter? (Attach time records and invoices to the deposition as an exhibit.)
5. Do you anticipate performing any further work before you testify at trial
6. Did anyone assist you? Do you contemplate assistance from anyone in the future on this matter? Identify your assistants. What did each assistant do?
7. Have you reached any tentative opinion regarding the issues in the lawsuit?
8. Please list each opinion you have formed, without giving me the reasons or details supporting the opinions. Are there any other opinions you have that you have not told me of?
9. As to each opinion, ask:
a. What are your reasons for each opinion?
b. State all assumptions in reaching each opinion.
c. Identify all data supporting each opinion.
d. Identify all evidence, documents, or photographs you examined or considered to arrive at that opinion.
e. Have you given me all the reasons supporting that opinion?
10. Have you ever read any materials pertaining to the subject of the opinion? Identify all such works. (Purpose here is to find impeaching material.) What is the title of publication, substance of contents, how expert became aware of the publication, etc?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

